Live Review: Belle & Sebastian in San Francisco
Ten years after the release of Belle and Sebastian's debut, 1996's "Tigermilk," fans might think they now know everything there is to know about this acclaimed Scottish indie-pop band. Well, think again.
The group's recently released CD, "The Life Pursuit," showed that Belle and Sebastian still has some tricks left up its sleeve. The band, which takes its name from a French children's TV series, pursued numerous different styles and feels on this disc, most notably '70s dance music. There are even some true electric guitar rock moments, which isn't something one normally thinks of with Belle and Sebastian.
Likewise, the band's show on Tuesday night (3/21) at the Concourse at the San Francisco Design Center felt very different than other Belle and Sebastian shows. There were more dance beats, a la Madonna or Erasure, and more keyboard-fueled new wave. There was less British schoolboy charm, which has traditionally been Belle and Sebastian's calling card, and more of what vocalist Stuart Murdoch referred to as 1985-era gay-disco moments. Think of a very twee version of the Scissor Sisters and you start to get the picture.
Not everything worked, especially the revved-up versions of once more-precious older songs, but it was still a mostly likable evening of solid indie-pop. The venue, however, worked against the band. Due to its long, narrow configuration, the 3,500-capacity space actually feels nearly as big as an arena floor. It's not an intimate space, which makes enjoying the band's often intimate music difficult.
That might have had something to do with why the crowd seemed less excited about this show then other Belle and Sebastian gigs in the past.
"You're a very civilized crowd," remarked vocalist Stuart Murdoch, choosing to take a positive spin on the audience's behavior. "Your mother brought you up well."
The band did a good job balancing older fan favorites with new selections from "The Life Pursuit." Murdoch and company kicked off the concert with a peppy version of "The Stars of Track and Field" from 1996's sophomore effort "If You're Feeling Sinister" and then delivered a bright rendition of the Western-tinged "Another Sunny Day" (from "The Life Pursuit").
The group stayed with "Pursuit" for the strange and awkward "Funny Little Frog," a too-cutesy number that ranks as the new album's lowest point, and then further stumbled with a mildly psychedelic take on the title track of "If You're Feeling Sinister." It would quickly get worse on "Electronic Renaissance" (from 1996's "Tigermilk"), as the band shamelessly mixed disco and new wave in a campy way that would make Andy Bell of Erasure blush.
The band would regain its footing in the second half of the show and perform excellent versions of the sweet baseball-themed tune "Piazza, New York Catcher" (from 2003's "Dear Catastrophe Waitress") and the trumpet-rich "She's Losing It" (from "Tigermilk"). Belle and Sebastian finished up strong as the main set drew to a close with highly enjoyable renditions of the old fan favorites "I'm a Cuckoo" and "Judy and the Dream of Horses."
March 2006
23 - Portland, OR - Roseland Ballroom
24 - Vancouver, British Columbia - Commodore
25 - Seattle, WA - Paramount
- Artist Links:
New Releases, Feb. 7: Belle & Sebastian, Beth Orton, Jack Johnson [February 2006]
Belle & Sebastian return to North America behind new album [January 2006]
Briefly: System of a Down, Belle & Sebastian, New Order, Gary Glitter [November 2005]
Belle & Sebastian make the most of their time in the U.S [February 2004]
CD Review: Belle & Sebastian, "Dear Catastrophe Waitress" (Sanctuary) [October 2003]
Weekend Ticketing: AC/DC, Harry Connick Jr., Smashing Pumpkins, Usher, Coldplay
Beastie Boys and friends get out the vote
3 Doors Down sketch out makeup dates
Rachael Yamagata leads 'Elephants' on tour
Calexico lines up stateside run for November
Rachael Yamagata: Exclusive Video Performance At LiveDaily Sessions
Carrie Rodriguez: Exclusive Video Performance At LiveDaily Sessions
Judith Owen: Exclusive Solo Set At LiveDaily Sessions
Rademacher: Exclusive Video Performance At LiveDaily Sessions
Calico Horse: Live And Acoustic At LiveDaily Sessions
Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Festival in San Francisco 2008
David Byrne in San Francisco CA 2008
John Legend in Berkeley California 2007
The Pretenders in Sacramento CA 2007
Nikka Costa in Los Angeles CA 2008
Jonas Brothers at Mountain View CA 2008
Butthole Surfers in Austin Texas 2008
Cowboy Mouth at Voodoo Fest New Orleans 2006
Austin City Limits Music Festival 2008
Ben Folds in Boston MA 2008

