Live Review: Good Charlotte and Sum 41 in Mesa, AZ
The "it" boys of Good Charlotte --twins Joel and Benji Madden--aren't shy about playing up their appeal to young girls.
They make provocative conversation, raising the collective eyebrows of the parents in the audience. They repeatedly make vast proclamations of love, and tease the audience about "making out" with all of them.
Thus, Monday night's show (11/1) at Mesa Amphitheatre in Mesa, AZ, was a pseudo-gothic rendition of "The Stepford Wives." The crowd, mostly girls in their early teens, did everything to make their crushes happy, even though Good Charlotte seemed to be poking fun of them at times.
When Good Charlotte's crew was setting up their cemetery-themed stage, the cool wind blew giant black curtains just enough to give a sneak peek of the band. Fans went into a frenzy. Once the show began, lead vocalist Joel Madden merely had to clear his throat into the microphone before the screams were so deafening they rivaled a Backstreet Boys concert.
In between tightly wound songs, Good Charlotte playfully posed on stage, or approvingly pointed at young girls who attempted to dress "punk."
With his hoarse vocals, Benji Madden spared no shame in announcing that Arizona was the home to some of the most beautiful people in the world. During a breakdown in the song "My Bloody Valentine," Benji Madden encouraged the crowd to sing along with them.
"Let's all sing it together and put your hands in the air and sing it together like a choir of, I don't know, Arizona angels."
And then: "One time I fell in love with a woman from Arizona," Madden said. "She was an evil bitch from hell. All she left me with was a broken heart, empty wallet and a couple of STDs."
Prepubescent fans looked quizzingly at their parents or guardians for a brief explanation. Luckily, Good Charlotte quickly rolled into a bouncy version of "Girls and Boys," alleviating any uncomfortable feelings.
But Madden continued his sex-education lecture when the song wrapped. "Sex is a very serious thing. Wear a condom."
His brother continued, "A lot of your parents might not want to talk to you about that but we will because we love you. We want to love you but we want to be safe."
Some would argue that Good Charlotte's punk-rock style was purchased at a mall, but it was all good to the crowd. The band's sweet-natured boyish looks--complete with shirts, ties, sweaters and dress pants--clashed with the Alice Cooper-like eye makeup.
Joel Madden's eye makeup is apparently a big point of contention among the female sect. While waiting in line to be frisked for security, two teenage girls debated the eyeliner design that Joel currently prefers. If they saw girls sporting the wrong look, they verbally slayed them.
Toronto-based co-headliners Sum 41 played off of their sophomoric humor, starting with the introduction of the show. The band showed a video of two of its members, drummer Steve Jocz and bassist Cone McCaslin, playing basketball. Jocz avenges his loss by beating McCaslin to death, dragging him back to his apartment, chopping him up and eating him.
Early in the show, diminutive guitarist/vocalist Deryck Whibley made Anna Nicole Smith his victim.
"Well, well, well, well. This next song is about a really, really stupid blonde girl with her own reality show, Anna Nicole Smith," he said before unleashing a stream of profanities.
Sum 41 primarily performed songs from its latest album, "Chuck," while trickling in hits such as "Fat Lip," during which the audience and the band traded vocal licks. The group's Metallica influence was evident in Whibley's and axe-man Dave Baksh's shredding guitar solos.
Like Good Charlotte, Sum 41's show featured lots of posturing. Sum 41 encouraged the audience to give the 41 salute--four fingers with one hand, and a middle finger with the other.
November 2004
3 - Orem, UT - McKay Events Center
4 - Denver, CO - Fillmore Auditorium
6 - St. Paul, MN - Roy Wilkins Auditorium
7 - Milwaukee, WI - Eagles Ballroom
9 - Chicago, IL - Aragon Ballroom
10 - Grand Rapids, MI - DeltaPlex
11 - Pittsburgh, PA - A.J. Palumbo Center
12 - Akron, OH - Rhodes Arena
13 - Buffalo, NY - Flickinger Athletic Center
14 - Lowell, MA - Tsongas Arena
15 - Sayerville, NJ - Starland Ballroom
18 - New Orleans, LA - Star Palace Theater
19 - Austin, TX - Austin Music Hall
20 - Grand Prairie, TX - Nokia Live
22 - Houston, TX - Verizon Wireless Theater
- Artist Links:
Benji Madden: Good Charlotte's sound still growing [July 2008]
Boys Like Girls, Good Charlotte share the stage [May 2008]
Back injury sidelines Sum 41 [October 2007]
Sum 41's Deryck Whibley talks 'Underclass Hero' [August 2007]
NOW 25 holds on to No. 1 [August 2007]
Sum 41 ships new album, maps fall tour [July 2007]
Weekend Ticketing: AC/DC, Harry Connick Jr., Smashing Pumpkins, Usher, Coldplay
Beastie Boys and friends get out the vote
3 Doors Down sketch out makeup dates
Rachael Yamagata leads 'Elephants' on tour
Calexico lines up stateside run for November
Rachael Yamagata: Exclusive Video Performance At LiveDaily Sessions
Carrie Rodriguez: Exclusive Video Performance At LiveDaily Sessions
Judith Owen: Exclusive Solo Set At LiveDaily Sessions
Rademacher: Exclusive Video Performance At LiveDaily Sessions
Calico Horse: Live And Acoustic At LiveDaily Sessions
Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Festival in San Francisco 2008
David Byrne in San Francisco CA 2008
John Legend in Berkeley California 2007
The Pretenders in Sacramento CA 2007
Nikka Costa in Los Angeles CA 2008
Jonas Brothers at Mountain View CA 2008
Butthole Surfers in Austin Texas 2008
Cowboy Mouth at Voodoo Fest New Orleans 2006
Austin City Limits Music Festival 2008
Ben Folds in Boston MA 2008

